Fear of change or fear of oneself?

by Marius Brusegard

In 2008, just below three percent of the world’s population were international migrants, according to “Immigration’s complexities, assimilations discontents” (2008), by the professor of sociology at University of California-Irvine, Rubén G. Rumbaut. This means that as much as 97 percent of the world’s population is still living in the countries where they were born.

It strikes me then, to hear about incidents like the one in which the Ecuadoran immigrant Marcelo Lucero was stabbed to death in Patchogue, N.Y., by 16- and 17-year old boys, as described in Anne Barnard’s article in New York Times (2009). The reasons for these attacks can be argued to be based on ideas such as racism or nationalism, or just the ignorance of youth feeling the urge to experiment with violence or such.

Another way of explaining the attacks can be fear, which the previously mentioned reasons also are rooted in. This being fear of competition in the job market, fear of cultures unknown to themselves, fear of changes etc. If the less than three percent of immigrants (on a world basis), creates enough fear to make someone kill another human being, that might either mean that some people are extremely easily scared, or that they do not need a good reason to become able to kill another human being.

In this case though, the Latino student population in Patchogue Medford School District had risen to 24 percent from 4 in 2003. However, this relatively fast growth of Latino students shouldn’t create as much fear as should be needed to perform the atrocities mentioned. After all, studies have shown that immigrants adjust to their new societies by language assimilation and such. As Rumbaut (2008) describes in his article, the Spanish language of immigrants is no longer spoken by the third generation, because of a switch to English. In fact, studies by Rumbaut and Alejandro Portes (2002) studies show that 95 percent of even Cuban-American children attending private bilingual schools actually preferred English.

Also, Rumbaut argues that according to numerous studies, immigrants are less likely to commit crimes or go to prison than the natives, in spite of the opposite misconception. These are all studies that show how the fear of differences in cultural values, or changes, or just immigrants in general, seems unfounded. The immigrants are adapting to their new societies, not the other way around.

America might be the country with the highest variety of nationalities in the world, and the citizens are almost all known to have heritage from outside of America. They call themselves Irish-American, French-American, Chinese-American and such. Yet in a country like that, it seems to be quite a lot of fear of and resistance towards immigrants, in spite of the American’s ancestors all having been immigrants not too long ago.

3 thoughts on “Fear of change or fear of oneself?

  1. America has a rich history of welcoming immigrants and of establishing laws to permit their legal entry and later naturalization. Our current disputes center most heavily on illegal immigrants who have compiled a mixed record. Some do very well and compete effectively with citizens for jobs. Others find themselves in difficulty and of that group, a smaller sub-group turns to crime as a way of life. Since we have legal avenues for qualified applicants to seek citizenship, those who do not quality tend to possess fewer attributes that make for success. Of those who turn to crime, some have become involved in the illegal drug trade. As we continue to draw down our finite petroleum resources, we are spending more heavily in energy research and exploration. Continue resource pressures have forced the price of gasoline up. Some communities are now facing $3.50 and $4.00 a gallon gasoline. We do not yet suffer the population pressures of Bangladesh or Rwanda, but the impact of rising population is easily visible. Many of our legal citizens now suffer from income stagnation, and high unemployment rates. Illegal immigration is only one of many factors contributing to our problems, but it is a factor.

  2. Pingback: Refugees and assimilation | JAPANsociology

  3. Pingback: Adolescence and migration: Struggling to fit in | JAPANsociology

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s